16
NFLPA report cards are annual evaluations conducted by the NFL Players Association, where players rate their teams based on various criteria, including treatment, facilities, and overall working conditions. The results provide insight into player satisfaction and team culture, influencing public perception and organizational changes.
Grades in the NFLPA report cards are determined through anonymous surveys completed by players. They assess various aspects of their team's environment, including coaching, medical staff, and support services. The feedback is aggregated to produce an overall grade for each team, ranging from A to F.
In the 2026 NFLPA report cards, the Miami Dolphins ranked first overall for the third consecutive year, reflecting high player satisfaction. Conversely, the Pittsburgh Steelers finished last, indicating significant dissatisfaction among their players, particularly concerning treatment and facilities.
The grades can significantly impact teams by influencing public perception, attracting or deterring potential players, and prompting management to make necessary changes. Poor grades may lead to organizational reviews and reforms, while high grades can bolster a team's reputation and recruitment efforts.
The NFL attempted to block the public release of the NFLPA report cards, citing concerns over the impact on teams. However, when the grades were leaked, the league sent a memo to teams stating they would review the situation, indicating a need to address the fallout from the leaks.
Players commonly report issues related to treatment of families, dining conditions, and overall support from the organization. For instance, the Cincinnati Bengals received low grades for family treatment and food quality, highlighting areas needing improvement in player welfare.
Past report cards have shown trends in player satisfaction, with some teams consistently ranking high or low. The 2026 report cards reflect ongoing issues, such as the Dolphins' sustained excellence and the Steelers' decline, suggesting that some organizations have not made necessary improvements over the years.
Teams often make changes based on feedback from report cards. For example, organizations may improve facilities, enhance player support services, or adjust coaching strategies. Positive changes can lead to improved grades in subsequent years, demonstrating responsiveness to player concerns.
The NFLPA oversees the survey process, ensuring player anonymity and the integrity of the feedback. This independent organization represents players' interests, facilitating the collection and analysis of data to provide a comprehensive overview of team environments across the league.
Historically, team evaluations in NFLPA report cards have shown patterns of consistency and change. Teams like the Dolphins have maintained high rankings, while others, such as the Steelers, have struggled. These trends reflect broader organizational health and the effectiveness of management practices over time.
